Login | Store | Training | Contact Us  
 Lates News 
 Product List 
 Related Links 

   Home
    

California Credit Freeze Law Declared Unconstitutional

By Colleen Morgan Svelnis, J.D., Writer Analyst, CCH Financial Privacy Law Guide.

The California state credit freeze law has been declared unconstitutional by a state appellate court. California Civil Code Sec. 1785.11.2 known as the “security freeze” law, allows a consumer to place a notice on his or her credit report to prevent credit reporting agencies from releasing credit information without affirmative permission. The plaintiff credit reporting agency prepares credit reports drawn in “material” part from public records, including court documents. The law violates the First Amendment because it precludes the reporting of information contained in public records.

The security freeze statute was enacted as part of legislation intended to protect consumers from identity theft in three principal ways:

  • allowing consumers to place fraud alerts on their credit reports;
  • permitting them to prevent or control the release of their credit reports; and
  • prohibiting specified government and business uses of Social Security numbers.

The trial court had determined the law unconstitutional with respect to information included in the consumer credit reports that is culled from public records. The trial court enjoined the credit reporting agency from disclosing information contained in or obtained from matters of public record. The appellate court concluded that the statute was unconstitutional and could not be judicially reformed as applied to the credit reporting agency; however, the law was not invalid on its face and in its entirety.

The credit reporting agency provides landlords and property managers with reports about prospective tenants. The public records consist of:

  • unlawful detainer court cases;
  • judicial foreclosure cases;
  • non-judicial foreclosures;
  • federal bankruptcy cases;
  • federal and state tax liens from the County Recorder's office;
  • criminal court matters; and
  • other federal and state civil court cases related to real estate issues.

Credit reports obtained from the credit reporting agencies typically include “identification and employment information and credit history, including the creditor's name, payment history and nature and limit of credit.”

Test for Commercial Speech

The appellate court applied the Central Hudson test for commercial speech to the law and determined that the legislation did not survive the scrutiny. Thus, the law also would not survive the strict scrutiny standard applicable to noncommercial speech. Additionally, the court found that the statute could not be reformed to conform it to constitutional requirements. Legislative history was such that the court could not confidently say that the trial court's proposed re-writing of the statute, or any other redrafting, would “closely effectuate policy judgments clearly articulated” by the Legislature. The California Legislature intended to allow consumers to prevent disclosure of any information in a credit reporting agency report; not merely the data “contained in and/or obtained from public records” as the trial court's reformation order permits. There was no evidence the legislature intended to enact a statute that permitted a consumer to freeze disclosure of everything except information from public records.

U.D. Registry v. California (CalAppCt)

     
Free White Papers

A Retrospective of the Troubled Asset Relief Program

By Katalina M. Bianco, J.D.

Download PDF


Credit Card Reform: An Analysis of the Credit CARD Act

By Katalina M. Bianco, J.D.

Download PDF


Comparative Analysis of Non-U.S. Bank Regulatory Reform and Banking Structure

By Gregg D. Killoren, J.D.

Download PDF


The Cost of FACT Act Compliance: New Research Study Finds that Financial Institutions Are Underestimating Cost

By Adam Elliott

Download PDF


Financial Regulation Reform: What to Expect in the 111th Congress

By James Hamilton

Download White Paper


The Other Bailout: How the Fed Is Financing the Financiers, and Related SEC Disclosure

By Mark S. Nelson

Download White Paper


The Economic Bailout: An Analysis of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act

By Katalina M. Bianco and John M. Pachkowski
 
Download White Paper

Product Spotlight
Bankruptcy Law Guide

  

New bankruptcy legislative requirements and changing economic conditions have drastically increased the amount of information required to handle this costly and uncertain area of law. The Bankruptcy Law Reporter provides all the most up-to-date information necessary to navigate the maze of bankruptcy law. Whether it's simply ensuring your company is on solid legal and financial ground, settling court disputes or protecting your own personal interests in a corporate or personal case, the answers are all here.
 
More Info...
Bank Digest
Bank Digest tracks the latest banking activity, regulatory changes and trends in federal banking policy. Each day, Bank Digest provides both a concise abstract and the full text of that day's releases from the federal agencies that impact the banking industry. Bank Digest also provides additional detail of significant events in weekly and monthly features.
 
More Info...
Consumer Credit Guide
In the past, many states have attempted to cure problems and abuses that have appeared on a "one-at-a-time" basis, resulting in a multiplicity of consumer credit laws. In addition, the federal government has injected standards into broad areas of consumer credit previously regulated only by the states. The CCH Consumer Credit Guide publishes the information that you need to succeed in the complex area of state and federal consumer credit laws and regulations.
 
More Info...
Financial Privacy
Law Guide

This product provides comprehensive coverage of federal and state laws, regulations, interpretations and decisions. The Guide covers data security, insurance and health information privacy, fair credit reporting, bank secrecy, identity theft, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, the E-Sign Act, the Electronic Fund Transfer Act, the Freedom of Information Act, the Right to Financial Privacy Act and international privacy.
More Info...
State Banking Law Reporter

Expedite your research with the CCH© State Banking Law Reporter. Now there's a single source for state banking law, giving banking professionals and legal counsel ready access to the information you need. State Banking Law Reporter combines the full text of state laws and regulations with authoritative explanations and consistent, topical organization.
 
More Info...

  
 

   ©2001-2024 CCH Incorporated or its affiliates
Print this Page | About Us | Privacy Policy | Site Map