Franchisee and Counsel Sanctioned for Filing Frivolous Action

 by Peter Reap, Legal Editor, CCH Business Franchise Guide.

Oil Company Could Not Have Violated Open Price Term

A class of all gasoline dealers who owned or operated gasoline station franchises in Texas under a franchisor's brand and entered into a standard dealer agreement failed to adequately allege that the franchisor breached the open price term in their agreements, the Texas Supreme Court has decided. The dealers failed to allege that the open prices charged by the franchisor were commercially unreasonable in amount or discriminatory. Therefore, a ruling by a Texas state trial court certifying the class of dealers and a Texas appellate court decision that affirmed the trial court's ruling (¶13,600, BUSINESS FRANCHISE GUIDE 2007-2008 New Developments Transfer Binder) were reversed. The dispute was remanded to the trial court to determine the effect of the instant breach of contract ruling on the requirements for class certification.

The dealers brought suit against the oil company, alleging that-unbeknownst to them-the oil company added the cost of its gasoline rebate programs back into the wholesale price the company charged the dealers for gasoline. Accepting the dealers' assertion that theirs was a contract action only, their complaint that they never received the rebate benefits promised by the oil company was simply the basis for their claim that the oil company did not act in good faith and therefore breached the open price provision, according to the court.

The lower courts failed to correctly construe and apply the Texas Supreme Court's ruling in Shell Oil Co. v. HRN, Inc. (BUSINESS FRANCHISE GUIDE 2004-2005 New Developments Transfer Binder ¶12,885), the court determined. In HRN, the high court concluded that to avoid having a jury determine in every open price term case whether there was any improper motive animating the price-setter, even if the prices charged were within the range of those charged throughout the industry, the good faith required by the Uniform Commercial Code's (UCC's) open price term provision had to be measured objectively, with reference to commercial realities, rather than subjectively, based on the price-setter's motives or alleged dishonesty. Thus, the dealers' claim in HRN failed because they did not allege that the prices charged them were commercially unreasonable or discriminatory.

The trial court distinguished HRN because of the dealers' "specific claims of dishonesty in fact based on [the oil company's] promise of a rebate and acts allegedly taken to remove the benefit promised." However, such a perceived distinction was without merit, according to the Texas Supreme Court. The dealers' claims of dishonesty in HRN were just as specific, and certainly as reprehensible, as those asserted by the dealers in this case, the court noted. As in HRN, there was no claim that the open prices charged were commercially unreasonable in amount or discriminatory. Here, the dealers pointed to nothing in their contracts that prohibited the oil company from taking rebate costs into account in setting prices.

The Texas appellate court distinguished HRN because this case involved "specific promises of economic renumeration for keeping stores open specified hours and selling specified volumes of gasoline." However, the instant dealers did not assert a cause of action for breach of such promises, the supreme court clarified. They disavowed any claim of fraud, and did not assert that any promises made to them by the franchisor constituted a contract or modified their sales agreements. Thus, the dealers' claim in the instant case lacked merit. The good faith safe harbor provided in the UCC's open price term provision would be undermined if, without more, an allegation of subjective bad faith trumped the normal case presumption of good faith, the court commented.

Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Gill, Tex Sup Ct., ¶14,283.

 

 

 


 


 

(The news featured above is a selection from the Business Franchise Guide newsletter, which is published monthly and distributed to subscribers of the Business Franchise Guide.)