(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in SEC Today, which is distributed to
subscribers of SEC
Today.)
Glassman Reviews Five SEC
Initiatives At ALI-ABA Institute
SEC Commissioner Cynthia Glassman, in remarks to the
ALI-ABA Financial Services Institute, reviewed five recent initiatives that are
intended to improve the information available to shareholders, investors and the
market, including executive compensation, Sarbanes-Oxley Act
section 404,
a new point of sale disclosure document, the investment adviser/broker-dealer
rule and the SEC's new corporate penalty guidelines. Everyone benefits when
disclosure meets not only the letter, but also the spirit of the disclosure
requirements, she said.
The SEC's proposed rules to improve disclosure about
executive compensation are intended to provide clear and comprehensive
information in a form that is useful to the market and investors, according to
Glassman. The gap between executive pay and the average worker has increased
dramatically over the last couple of decades, Glassman noted, which is
particularly disturbing when executives are highly compensated at a company that
performs poorly. The current disclosure rules make it difficult to determine
total compensation. The proposed rules will require the disclosure of a single
number representing the total compensation for the highest paid officers and
employees and will include a new narrative called compensation discussion and
analysis in which the compensation policies and decisions will be described.
Glassman said the proposed disclosure should make boards or
management teams think twice about the levels of compensation. If they are not
comfortable with the amount they must reveal, they may be paying too much, she
explained. Glassman expects a lot of comments will focus on the disclosure of
perks, which must be detailed at lower thresholds under the proposal.
She noted that the valuation of stock options may raise
questions such as whether it should be assumed that the named executives stay
through the vesting period. This approach would permit more accurate comparisons
across companies but would raise the estimated value of the options, she noted.
Glassman supports the initiative to improve the disclosure of executive
compensation and hopes that a final rule can be quickly adopted.
Many of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act rules have achieved positive
results, according to Glassman, including the CEO and CFO certification
requirements and the independent regulatory structure for auditors. Section 404,
however, resulted in some unintended consequences that led to widespread
criticism of its costs and burdens. Glassman said there is little doubt that the
assessment of internal controls had shifted from a risk-based assessment by
management to a non-risk-based exercise by the auditors with a focus on controls
for controls' sake. She hopes the joint SEC/PCAOB guidance will refocus
companies and their auditors on the appropriate approach to
section 404
in the second year of compliance.
Glassman said she is still concerned about the misfocus of
the section 404
process and its costs. She will be watching for a more risk-based approach in
year two in which the scope of the audit is related to the level of risk. By
risk, Glassman said she means in the context of management's perspective on what
is important to the business and to the financial reports. If there is not a
significant refocus in year two, Glassman said the SEC and the PCAOB should
consider ways to make the process more effective and efficient, including a
revisit of Auditing Standard No. 2.
Glassman is enthusiastic about the SEC's proposed point of
sale disclosure proposal that would deliver information about fees, costs and
broker conflicts of interest at the time investors are making their investment
decision. The balancing of costs and benefits has been a challenge, she said.
Glassman said disclosure was also an important part of the analysis of the
investment adviser/broker-dealer rule that was adopted last year to make clear
the different duties and obligations of investment professionals. A number of
investor protection concerns were raised during the rulemaking process. The SEC
decided to conduct a study on the differences in the regulatory framework
applicable to broker-dealers and investment advisers. Glassman said she believes
the study is critical and hopes it will be organized as quickly as possible.
Glassman reviewed the SEC's guidelines on the issuance of
corporate penalties. She is pleased with the guidelines, but acknowledged that
applying them is easier said than done. The SEC will have to figure out whether
the shareholders benefited from a fraud or were victimized by it, she explained,
which is not always a simple analysis.
Finally, Glassman reported that the SEC is continuing to
work with the banking agencies to find a solution under Regulation B that
protects investors without overburdening the compliance framework.
|