(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in Federal Securities Law Reporter,
which is distributed to subscribers of Federal
Securities Law Reporter.)
SEC Chairman Addresses Annual "SEC Speaks" Conference
SEC Chairman Christopher Cox delivered the opening remarks
at the Practising Law Institute's "SEC Speaks" conference in
Washington, DC. Cox reviewed the initiatives the SEC has undertaken in his 80
weeks as chairman, including the most comprehensive overhaul of the executive
compensation rules in a decade. That initiative could not have been more timely,
he said, given that the stock option backdating scandal was just coming to
light.
Chairman Cox said the SEC's investigations into backdating
practices illustrate the value of interactive data. The Forms 4 on which
executives report their stock option exercises were filed on paper prior to
2003. Once the SEC began receiving the Forms 4 in an interactive data format,
the information became much easier to analyze. He added that the SEC began to
tag the data from the archival Forms 4 using the XML format. The SEC also
adopted rules that accelerated the filing of the forms to within two days of the
option grants. The result of these initiatives was the discovery of billions of
dollars of backdated stock option awards.
Chairman Cox also talked about the technological
improvements underway at the SEC in addition to the interactive data initiative,
including a new system to track and distribute penalties and disgorgements and a
new system to ensure that the SEC continues to operate if a disaster strikes.
Mr. Cox also reviewed the Commission's enforcement process.
He said the SEC's "Wells" process, which provides an opportunity to
present a counter-argument to a potential enforcement action, is one of the most
striking models of fairness that exists in the federal system. The chairman
outlined a number of cases the SEC has brought in the past year ranging from
hedge fund frauds and insider trading to account intrusion schemes. During his
80-week tenure at the SEC, Mr. Cox said that over a billion dollars has been
distributed to injured investors.
In the last year, the chairman reported that the
Enforcement Division filed 37 emergency actions to stop fraudulent activity,
sought 46 emergency asset freezes and 97 officer and director bars. The division
halted trading in the securities of 71 issuers for the lack of adequate public
disclosure. Chairman Cox said it is a daunting task for the SEC's enforcement
officials to police the enormous capital markets, especially as the connections
with global markets continues to grow. He thanked the staff for its efforts in
protecting the integrity of the markets while encouraging capital formation and
economic growth.
Developments in Market Regulation
The Division of Market Regulation expects to recommend the
adoption of final rules this spring on proposals to prevent short sales during
the period before pricing and then purchasing the security in the offering, and
amendments to Regulation SHO. The staff expects to update its responses to
frequently asked questions about Regulation NMS in the next couple of weeks. The
staff also hopes to move quickly on its bank broker-dealer rules, which could be
finalized by summer.
Atkins Remarks
Commissioner Paul Atkins spoke about court decisions
overturning the SEC's mutual fund governance rules and its hedge fund adviser
registration rules, and Congressional action to prompt the SEC to adopt rules
for credit rating agencies and bank broker-dealer activities. Mr. Atkins
observed that Chairman Cox has taken the two judicial reprimands as an
opportunity to conduct a top-to-bottom review of the SEC's process for assessing
the economic impact of its rulemaking.
Commissioner Atkins also mentioned a case in which the SEC
was admonished in a Regulation FD case and one in which an insider trading case
was dismissed for lack of evidence. He does not believe these cases suggest a
systemic problem, but said they should be viewed as a lesson when deciding which
cases are strong enough to take to trial.
The SEC must remain focused on the due process rights of
those it investigates, according to Mr. Atkins. The SEC's ethics rules remind
the staff that the power to investigate carries with it the power to defame and
destroy, he said. He addressed the contentious issue of requests for waivers of
attorney-client privilege. While the Department of Justice has received the most
attention, the SEC has also been criticized.
It is easy to understand why government investigators want
respondents to waive, he said. However, Mr. Atkins said that any demand for
waivers by SEC examiners of broker-dealers or investment advisers is done
without the direct supervision of the Commission. Atkins said he would take a
very critical view of such requests and would question their appropriateness.
Commissioner Atkins advised that the president of the
American Bar Association has asked the SEC to reconsider its policies and
procedures regarding waivers. In particular, the ABA asked the SEC to revise its
Seaboard report which outlines the factors the SEC will consider when deciding
whether to grant credit for cooperation. The Seaboard report includes a footnote
relating to waivers, which has become the back door through which credit has
been given for waivers, according to Atkins. He does not view the waiver as a
factor in obtaining credit, and said he would refuse to consider for credit
purposes whether a respondent has waived the privilege.
The ABA has urged the SEC to delete the footnote from the
factors in receiving credit. Mr. Atkins said the SEC will carefully consider the
request. He also believes it is time for a review of all of the SEC's internal
policies and procedures related to protected information. The SEC should
consider whether to follow the example of the Department of Justice, he said,
and must ensure that all waiver requests are subject to these policies and
procedures.
|