(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in SEC Today, which is distributed to
subscribers of SEC
Today.)
Cox Testifies on JPMorgan/Bear Stearns Merger
SEC Chairman Christopher
Cox was among the witnesses testifying at yesterday's Senate Banking
Committee's hearing on the merger agreement between JPMorgan Chase & Co. and
Bear Stearns Companies, Inc. Cox said the actions by the Federal Reserve Board
to open the discount window to all of the major investment banks was
unprecedented and significant. Most of the senators' questions centered on the
actions of the Fed, Treasury and the New York Fed, but some questioned the SEC's
actions leading up to the crisis.
Ranking member
Richard Shelby (R-AL) noted that the SEC was the primary regulator of Bear
Stearns under the consolidated supervised entities program. Some have said the
SEC missed the boat, Shelby noted. He asked Cox when the SEC discovered Bear
Stearns' severe liquidity problem and what steps it took in response.
Cox advised that
Bear Stearns was on the SEC's watch list going back to the summer of 2007
because of the failures of its two hedge funds. The hedge funds were separate
entities, however, and posed no risk to the holding company until Bear Stearns
decided to support one of the funds. At that point, the SEC began to monitor
Bear Stearns' capital on a daily basis, according to Cox.
At the beginning of
the year, Bear Stearns continued to exceed the regulatory threshold for a well
capitalized firm. Cox said the SEC was in regular contact with the New York Fed
and its contacts increased since February. The SEC spoke with the New York Fed
numerous times on March 10 when Bear Stearns was denied not only unsecured
financing, but also short-term securities financing. Counterparties would not
provide securities lending services and clearing services. By the weekend of
March 15-16, Cox said Bear Stearns faced a choice of filing bankruptcy on Monday
or agreeing to merge with a larger partner. The speed with which it happened was
unprecedented, he said.
Cox responded to an
inquiry from Senator Tim Johnson (D-SD) about the consolidated entity program.
Cox explained that the liquidity measures under the program were thought to be
adequate. The existing models are designed to withstand the complete loss, for
an entire year, of all sources of unsecured funding, he explained. The models
anticipate that secured funding will continue to be available, although on less
favorable terms. The SEC is currently working with firms to ensure that they
have sufficient liquidity in the Bear Stearns stress scenario. Cox also wrote to
the Basel Committee to offer his support for its consideration of whether to
extend the capital adequacy standards to address liquidity risk.
Senator Jack Reed
(D-RI) questioned whether the run on Bear Stearns was partially due to efforts
to manipulate the market. Cox said that he could not comment on any potential
SEC investigations into market manipulation.
Senator Robert
Menendez (D-NJ) said he hated to think that the rumor mill could bring down such
a large investment bank. He asked what the SEC is doing to address the dynamics
of new complex instruments. Cox advised that the SEC is not waiting for new
regulations or legislation, but is working with the firms now with respect to
liquidity, risk practices and models
At the opening of
the hearing, Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-CT) said he believes the Fed
did the right thing by intervening in the Bear Stearns matter, but wanted to
investigate whether other alternatives were available. Shelby observed that it
was the first time since the Great Depression that the Fed has bailed out a
financial institution. He warned against the moral hazard that may encourage
other institutions to take undue risks with the expectation of a government
bailout if they run into trouble.
Senator Jim Bunning
(R-KY) criticized the bailout of Bear Stearns. He questioned why the
"invisible hand of the market" was not permitted to provide the
discipline. Regulators failed to do their job, in his view, since they let the
financial system become so fragile that a single firm could endanger the entire
system.
Fed Chairman Ben
Bernanke responded that the issue extended well beyond one company. The sudden
failure of Bear Stearns would have led to a chaotic unwinding of its financial
positions, he said, and the resulting damage would have been severe and
difficult to contain. It would have been felt broadly throughout the economy, he
said.
Robert Steel,
Treasury's Under Secretary for Domestic Finance, agreed. The focus was not on a
particular institution but its impact on the markets, he said. He believes the
agreements that were reached were both necessary and appropriate. Timothy
Geithner, the president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, noted that Bear
Stearns reached the brink of insolvency at a difficult time. The failure to act
would have posed a risk to the entire economy. The Fed acted as lenders of last
resort as authorized by Congress, he said.
Dodd raised
concerns about the price that was agreed upon in the merger of JP Morgan and
Bear Stearns. He suggested that it would be improper for a government official
to say what the appropriate price should be. Bernanke said that multiple firms
had the opportunity to talk to Bear Stearns. The price was secondary, he said.
Steel said that, since federal funds were involved, there was a view that the
price should not be very high. It should at the low end, he explained. Geithner
said the goal was to avert the risk of default and not add to the moral hazard
risk in this type of intervention. Both the original deal and the later price
increase were consistent with that outcome, he said.
Dodd asked how wise
it was to open the discount window to broker-dealers, noting that everyone
rejected that idea at a hearing 10 days prior to that action. Bernanke said the
conditions that evolved during the week of March 10 led to the Fed's decision.
The Fed is working with the SEC and the firms. Bernanke said the lending has
been done safely and soundly. The window was opened under emergency authority
and will have to be closed eventually.
|