(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in SEC Today, which is distributed to
subscribers of SEC
Today.)
Campos Sees Growing Interest in Mutual Recognition
SEC Commissioner Roel Campos believes the globalization of
securities markets and international securities regulation may be approaching a
critical mass. In remarks at IOSCO's annual conference in Mumbai, India, Campos
pointed to the recent NYSE-Euronext merger and to remarks by key SEC officials
about mutual recognition and cooperative approaches relating to foreign trading
screens and broker-dealers. Campos said it is time to consider the broader issue
of mutual recognition and the extent to which it can be accomplished. His
written remarks are posted on the SEC's Web site.
There are many issues that would have to be worked out with
respect to mutual recognition, according to Campos. For instance, it could be
difficult to impose more demanding standards on domestic issuers than on foreign
issuers whose securities are sold through screens. A reasonable degree of
regulatory convergence would help before instituting any new approaches, he
said. Campos believes it will take time and effort, as well as international
will and cooperation.
Campos reported that the SEC's roundtable on eliminating
the U.S. reconciliation requirement for financial statements prepared pursuant
to international financial reporting standards resulted in some provocative new
ideas, including whether U.S. companies should be given the choice of using IFRS
or U.S. GAAP. He added that former SEC Chief Accountant Donald Nicolaisen, who
first proposed the roadmap for eliminating the reconciliation requirement,
suggested that the SEC consider requiring all U.S. companies to use the same
standard as foreign companies, rather than giving them the choice. Campos said
it is interesting that people are now willing to consider previously taboo
subjects.
Since the pool of foreign companies that submitted their
2005 financial statements prepared using IFRS as promulgated by the IASB was
much smaller than expected, Campos said it may be necessary for issuers and
their auditors to have a serious discussion. He hopes that auditors can prepare
opinions stating that the audited financial statements were prepared according
to IFRS as promulgated by the IASB, and not solely in accordance with the
standards of a specific jurisdiction. To achieve the critical mass contemplated
by the roadmap, Campos said more companies must file audited financial
statements prepared in accordance with IFRS as promulgated by the IASB.
Campos reviewed the discussion at a recent open meeting,
which he described as the most unusual since he has been at the SEC. The staff
reviewed matters raised by commenters in response to the PCAOB's proposed
Auditing Standard No. 5 and the SEC's proposed guidance for management under
section 404. The issues raised at the meeting will be addressed by the SEC and
PCAOB staffs to finalize their respective proposals. Campos also made clear that
the revisions are not an attempt to roll back section 404 or to appease business
or audit industry interests, but to increase the effectiveness and the
efficiency of the audit process.
Campos reported that IOSCO's technical committee will host
a roundtable on June 1 on the quality of public company audits from a regulatory
perspective. The committee is also drafting a paper on contingency planning for
audit services. The roundtable will examine audit quality from a global
perspective and whether potential future developments will have an impact on
audit quality.
Campos said it is imperative that regulators consider
contingency planning given that there are only four major accounting firms
conducting the bulk of all public company audits. Campos said the paper will
likely consist of general guidance and broad suggestions on how contingency
plans can be written by securities regulators. It will not be overly specific,
he said, since many contingency plans will be confidential and countries' laws
differ.
Jacquelyn Lumb
|