(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in Federal Securities Law Reporter,
which is distributed to subscribers of Federal
Securities Law Reporter.)
PLI Panelists Review Developments in International Securities Markets
The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board's assistant
director for international affairs, Karen Dietrich, reported that the staff has
been able to resolve all of the disclosure problems it has encountered to date
during inspections of foreign audit firms. About 770 foreign audit firms from 84
countries are registered with the PCAOB, all but one of which are small firms
that are subject to a three-year inspection cycle. Ms. Dietrich also reported
that the PCAOB recently concluded its first international auditor regulatory
institute. Representatives from more than 40 countries attended the institute to
learn about the PCAOB's program. Ms. Dietrich spoke at the recent Practising Law
Institute conference on foreign issuers and the U.S. securities laws.
In 2007, Ms. Dietrich said the inspectors will be in 20
countries conducting inspections. Firms that register with the PCAOB to audit
public companies must cooperate with the PCAOB inspections. Some countries
prohibit the production of certain documents under confidentiality laws. She
said the PCAOB has no specific rule about the means by which a firm must
cooperate, but it may have to decline an engagement if it cannot obtain the
necessary assurances from the audit client.
D.J.Gannon, with Deloitte & Touche, noted that a fair
amount of diversity remains in international financial statements. It is not
unexpected that companies will use different GAAPs under the guise of one, he
said. This presents a real issue that is being worked out. The biggest challenge
is to arrive at a common perspective, he said. Mr. Gannon characterized
convergence as a process with harmonized benchmarks with everyone trying to get
to the same place.
During a panel discussion on adapting to U.S. governance
rules and executing audit committee responsibilities, Nicolas Grabar, with
Cleary Gottlieb, said the conscientiousness of U.S. audit committees is a fairly
recent development. For foreign companies, he questioned whether it is still
less than genuine. Duncan Wiggetts, legal counsel for PricewaterhouseCoopers
Eurofirms, responded that no one is giving tutorials on what it means to be an
audit committee of a U.S. sister company. The European Union will become used to
the concepts found in Section 10A reports and Section 404, he said.
Ethiopis Tafara, the SEC's director of the Office of
International Affairs, said that global markets call for global rules. His
office is pressing for the adoption of international financial reporting
standards and is communicating with the SEC's counterparts about the necessary
steps. Many fear that the SEC expects a certain degree of convergence or
complete convergence before it will eliminate its reconciliation requirement.
That is not so, according to Mr. Tafara. The SEC wants to see a process in place
so that U.S. GAAP and International Financial Reporting Standards do not
diverge.
By endorsing the consistent application of IFRS, Mr. Tafara
said the SEC is telling the public that it believes it can live with two
accounting standards, but not an extensive number of different systems. He
believes the SEC's counterparts understand that position. The international
community is building an infrastructure to accommodate IFRS, he said, and the
recently signed protocol with the European Union ensures that the conversation
will continue. In order to minimize conflicts, Mr. Tafara said that IOSCO and
CESR have developed databases to help ensure consistent interpretations.
Edward Greene, the general counsel for Citigroup Global
Corporate Investment Bank, talked about the recent article published by Mr.
Tafara offering a blueprint for cross-border access. The article outlines a
framework through which foreign exchanges and broker-dealers could seek an
exemption from SEC registration based on their compliance with substantively
similar foreign securities laws and regulations, and supervision by a foreign
securities regulator. The SEC would retain its jurisdiction to pursue violations
of the U.S. federal securities laws.
Mr. Greene said the proposal would only work if it started
out on a pilot basis. He believes the proposal has gotten some traction,
however. He said there is no way the SEC would agree to a lead regulator as far
as enforcement, but believes coordination in other areas is possible. Mr. Tafara
acknowledged the dangers of politicizing the process. He added that regulators
would have to be creative in how comparability is measured. They may have to be
willing to look at outcomes, as well as inputs, he said.
|