Meredith Cross, the director of the SEC’s
Division of Corporation Finance,
testified before the House Committee on
Financial Services on September 24 about the
agency’s plans for implementing the
executive compensation provisions in the
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer
Protection Act. The Committee also heard
testimony from officials from the Federal
Reserve Board and the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation, Martin Baily with the
Brookings Institution, and Darla Stuckey
with the Society of Corporate Secretaries
and Governance Professionals.
Section 951 of the Dodd-Frank
Act requires a shareholder advisory
say-on-pay vote on executive compensation at
all companies that are subject to the SEC’s
proxy rules. The votes must be held at least
once very three years. A separate advisory
vote must be held at least every six years
on whether the say-on-pay resolution will be
presented every one, two or three years.
Any proxy statement seeking
shareholder approval of a merger or a
similar transaction must disclose, and must
seek a shareholder advisory vote to approve,
the compensation related to the transaction
unless the transaction was already the
subject of a say-on-pay vote. Institutional
investment managers that are subject to 1934
Act Section 13(f) must report at least
annually on how they voted on any of the
required votes.
Cross noted that the
Dodd-Frank Act did not specify a deadline
for these rulemaking initiatives, but the
SEC’s goal is to adopt final rules in time
for the 2011 proxy season.
Section 957 of the Act
requires the national securities exchanges
to amend their rules to prohibit brokers
from voting uninstructed shares on the
election of directors, executive
compensation or any other significant
matters as determined by the SEC. Cross
advised that the SEC previously approved
changes to the New York Stock Exchange rules
to prohibit broker voting of uninstructed
shares in director elections. The SEC also
approved NYSE rules that prohibit broker
voting on all executive compensation
matters, which include the say-on-pay votes.
The SEC expects to consider corresponding
rules by the other national securities
exchanges in the near future.
Section 952 of the Act
requires the SEC to adopt rules to mandate
new listing standards for the independence
of compensation committee directors and to
establish new disclosure requirements and
conflict of interest standards in connection
with the hiring of compensation consultants.
The rules must be adopted within 360 days
from the date of enactment of the Dodd-Frank
Act. Cross said the rules should be proposed
for comment soon.
Section 953 requires the SEC
to amend its executive compensation
disclosure requirements to require companies
to disclose information about the
relationship between executive pay and
company performance. Companies will also
have to disclose the total annual
compensation of the chief executive officer,
the median annual total compensation of all
other employees and the ratio between the
two amounts. Rep. Patrick McHenry (R-NC)
noted that some have characterized this
provision as a logistical nightmare.
Cross said that in drafting
rules under Section 953, the staff will try
to address the difficulties the requirement
will pose for large, multinational firms. If
the staff runs into problems, it will return
to Congress for assistance. Committee Chair
Barney Frank (D-MA) noted that the provision
was added by the Senate. He offered to
revise the language if necessary.
Section 955 requires the SEC
to adopt amendments to require companies to
disclose in their annual meeting proxy
materials whether any employee or director
is permitted to purchase financial
instruments designed to hedge against any
decrease in the market value of equity
securities granted as part of their
compensation.
Section 954 requires rules
mandating changes to the listing standards
to require companies to implement and
disclose clawback policies for recovering
incentive-based pay from current and former
executive officers during any three-year
period that precedes any accounting
restatement due to material non-compliance
with the financial reporting requirements.
The Act does not specify deadlines for these
three sections, but Cross said the SEC’s
goal is to publish rule proposals by July
2011
The SEC is also working to
implement Section 956 which requires that
the agency work with other federal
regulators to develop joint regulations or
guidelines applicable to covered financial
institutions, which include SEC-registered
broker-dealers and investment advisers with
assets of $1 billion or more. Cross said
this is a new role for the SEC. The rules or
guidelines relate to the structures of
incentive-based compensation and prohibit
incentive-based payment arrangements which
regulators believe may encourage
inappropriate risks. The rules will be
comparable to the standards applicable to
insured depository institutions. The Act
requires that the rules or guidelines be
adopted no later than nine months after the
enactment of the Dodd-Frank Act.