(The news featured
below is a selection from the news covered in SEC Today, which is distributed to
subscribers of SEC
Today.)
Nazareth
Discusses Conflicts of Interest and Risk Management at SIA Luncheon
Annette Nazareth, the director of the SEC's Division of
Market Regulation, reviewed some of the conflicts of interest that firms have
reported after conducting in-depth reviews and some of the emerging risk
management challenges in the hedge fund industry in recent remarks to the
Securities Industry Association. The securities industry is fraught with
conflicts of interest, she said. If left unaddressed, these conflicts can
undermine investor trust and confidence in the fairness of the markets, she
said.
Nazareth
's written remarks were posted on the SEC's Web site.
Nazareth
described the conflicts that broker-dealers and their affiliated asset managers
revealed in presentations to the SEC and urged others to review and consider the
issues in their own firms' internal control structures. One area in which
numerous conflicts may arise is where a financial services firm trades both as
agent in facilitating customer orders and as principal for the firm.
Nazareth
warned against trading ahead of the publication of research reports or trading
based on knowledge about a customer's portfolio securities or a future
underwriting deal. She noted that even a simple inquiry by a research analyst
about the market, prevailing prices or the value of a security could tip off
traders who may use the information for trades.
Nazareth
added that confidential customer information could be overheard where agency
and proprietary traders are located next to each other. In some instances, the
proprietary trading group may have access to the equity product group's data on
securities positions and trading activity. Firms must construct information
barriers to block access to confidential information and should identify and
discipline any individuals who misuse the trust of the customer or the firm, she
said.
Conflicts in the fixed income area differ somewhat because
of the manner in which it trades, according to
Nazareth
. Firms must tailor their internal processes and controls specifically for fixed
income to address those key differences, she said. The trading desk for fixed
income instruments is a fertile area for market-sensitive information, she
explained. Firms and compliance staff must structure and supervise fixed income
operations so that the necessary information sharing occurs without eliminating
the information barriers that are necessary to preserving customer and
proprietary confidential information.
Nazareth
added that the preservation of information barriers is a primary concern and a
source of conflicts in the fixed income area.
Nazareth
noted that many of the conflicts that she addressed are not new, but the manner
in which they arise may be novel as industry products and services change and
new participants enter the markets. Compliance officers must be aware of
industry trends and promptly resolve any conflicts that may arise in the course
of their business.
Nazareth
said that her second topic, prime brokerage for hedge funds, merits legal,
compliance and risk operations personnel to consider in connection with their
risk management practices. The hedge fund prime brokerage business is highly
competitive, she said, and prime brokers are offering an ever-expanding list of
services to capture new business or to expand existing relationships. These
ancillary activities present numerous conflicts of interest, she said, as well
as considerable risk management issues.
Prime brokerage firms are vulnerable to decreases in their
primary businesses, according to
Nazareth
, such as equity and debt trading. Most material risks arise from large
exposures to fairly standard products, she said, so even small changes in
relevant risk factors can have a major impact. Prime brokerage firms'
relationships with hedge funds pose different risk management challenges, she
said. Hedge funds' participation in new products has fundamentally affected the
market for these products, she advised, which can also affect broker-dealers
that trade those products.
Nazareth
noted that hedge funds interact with brokers as prime brokerage customers as
well as counterparties to OTC derivatives transactions. Broker-dealers
increasingly have counterparty credit exposure to hedge funds.
Nazareth
said that broker-dealers should integrate their risk management practices
across business units to avoid undue risk exposure arising from counterparties
strategizing how they transact with broker-dealers to avoid margin or collateral
requirements.
The size and market activity of the hedge fund industry
cannot be ignored, according to
Nazareth
. She said that risk managers must understand the scope of the firms'
relationship across business groups and affiliates to assess their risk
exposure. Risk management must create policies to protect against risks where
the markets show signs of fundamental changes and market participants are
vulnerable.
Finally,
Nazareth
said that, given hedge funds' lack of transparency, broker-dealers must have
the appropriate margin to cover current and potential exposure, particularly if
the counterparty is a weak credit.
|