(The news
featured below is a selection from the news covered in the Federal Securities
Report Letter, which is distributed to subscribers of the Federal
Securities Law Reports.)
SEC Prohibits Use
of Directed Brokerage to Distribute Fund Shares
The SEC adopted amendments to prohibit the use of brokerage commissions to
finance the distribution of fund shares. The commissioners also voted unanimously
to adopt new disclosure requirements about fund portfolio managers. The NASD
is expected to adopt a parallel amendment to its rules to prohibit broker-dealers
from selling shares of a fund if the fund's manager or distributor considers
the sale of fund shares in selecting broker-dealers to execute the transactions.
The SEC staff also advised that it is considering additional recommendations
for further amendments to the rule based on the hundreds of comment letters
received.
The prohibition on directing fund portfolio brokerage transactions to broker-dealers
to compensate them for promoting the sale of fund shares is intended to eliminate
a serious conflict of interest between funds and their advisers that can
compromise the best execution for the transaction. The SEC recognized that
funds may need to use selling brokers to effect portfolio securities transactions
in order to obtain the best execution, however, and will permit the use of
selling brokers as long as the fund or its adviser has adopted policies and
procedures to prevent the consideration of brokers' distribution efforts
and any agreements under which a fund is expected to direct brokerage commissions
for distribution.
Some of the commenters had urged the SEC to adopt a safe harbor in connection
with the prohibition on directed brokerage, but the staff concluded that
it was unnecessary. Chairman William Donaldson asked what the staff will
look for when it examines funds' policies and procedures. Associate Director
Robert Plaze said the staff will look at the role of the chief compliance
officer and suggested that chief compliance officers should test for a correlation
between distribution and sales to ensure there are no informal arrangements.
The NASD's rule will apply to broker-dealers selling fund shares to help
ensure that informal arrangements do not exist.
Commissioner Harvey Goldschmid said that prohibiting directed brokerage makes
sense. The practice has grown dramatically in recent years, he noted, and
in his view, best execution is the issue of most concern because it is difficult
to monitor. Best execution will not cure directed brokerage, he added. Associate
Director Plaze agreed that best execution is very hard to enforce. The staff
recognized that selling brokers are needed in today's market, he said, so
it would not support a rule to prohibit their use.
Commissioner Paul Atkins asked the staff to streamline the release and make
it clearer. He said the release should contain the same plain English that
is expected of others. Commissioner Roel Campos said he has no doubt that
some funds will try to shift costs to make up for the lack of directed brokerage,
so the SEC is not finished examining this area.
Portfolio Manager Disclosure
The amendments to Forms N-1A, N-2, N-3 and N-CSR were adopted with modifications
from the proposing release. The new disclosure will require the identification
of portfolio management team members primarily responsible for managing the
portfolio. If there are more than five members, funds must disclose information
about the five with the most primary responsibilities. Funds will also be
required to disclose in their statements of additional information any other
accounts managed by the fund's manager, such as hedge funds or pension plans,
and the total assets in those accounts. Funds must explain any conflicts
of interest that may arise in connection with the management of multiple
accounts.
Funds will also be required to disclose in their statements of additional information
the structure of their compensation arrangements for portfolio managers,
such as performance benchmarks and the period for reaching those benchmarks.
Funds must also disclose information about the shares the managers own in
the funds they manage. The SEC will encourage funds to make their statements
of additional information more readily available to shareholders by posting
them on their Web sites.
Commissioner Cynthia Glassman, while voting for the amendments, said that she
continues to be concerned about information overload and thought the staff's
estimates of the costs of the amendments seemed low. Commissioner Atkins
agreed with Ms. Glassman and emphasized the need for a full-scale review
of the SEC's disclosure requirements.
In his opening remarks, Chairman Donaldson noted that after yesterday's meeting,
only three rulemaking initiatives remained outstanding out of the 13 initiatives
begun last fall to address problems in the mutual fund industry. He expects
the Commission to act on those proposals this year.
¨ The adopting releases will be published in a forthcoming REPORT.
|